Bizarre Game 5 One For The Ages

by Danny Gallagher | Posted on Friday, October 16th, 2015
Facebook Twitter Plusone

Martin and Gibbons

I got home from work with a pizza just about the time chaos erupted at the Rogers Centre.

It was, what, close to 6:15 Wednesday night when I looked at the television to see a ball thrown by Jays catcher Russell Martin somehow end up rolling toward third base. Not knowing what really happened as I took off my shoes, I thought Martin had double-pumped a throw and the ball somehow left his hand inadvertently.

Then I found out Martin had hit the left hand or bat belonging to Shin-Soo Choo of the Rangers, setting off a charade of events that would follow. Rougned Odor came home to score on the Martin error, as the official scorer ruled it, and after a series of discussions involving the umpiring crew, the two managers and the people in New York checking replays, the run counted.

Choo was still in the batter’s box, the play was still alive and no time had been called by home-plate umpire Dale Scott, a veteran of decades as an arbiter.

Fans started throwing debris everywhere to dispute the call, allowing a bizarre run to score. But the Jays got their vengeance in the bottom half of the seventh. The Rangers made three errors, four, if you count Odor’s puzzling misplay of an innocuous, seemingly innocent, short flare out his way by Josh Donaldson.

The third error made by shortstop Elvis Andrus came on what was an easy throw to him at the knees by third baseman Adrian Beltre, who was fielding a sacrifice bunt by Ryan Goins. Beltre walked away, putting his hands on his head, shaking in disbelief because Andrus didn’t catch his throw.

Then Jose Bautista, in the biggest home run in Jays’ franchise history since Joe Carter’s blast on Oct. 23, 1993, shook the earth in Toronto, all of Ontario, Canada and America with a mammoth shot off Sam Dyson to give the Jays a 6-3 cushion which they never gave up.

The flip of the bat by Bautista, an insult to the Rangers, showed Bautista’s passion nine times over. An unbelievable feeling for him, his teammates and fans in Toronto and the rest of the country.

My recollection of Carter’s home run is that Phillies reliever Mitch Williams threw down and in to Carter. And Dyson threw the same pitch, down and in to Bautista.

But, you know, there was still that feeling of edginess and concern even with a three-run lead. To see Roberto Osuna, all of 20, striking out the side in the top of the ninth was enlightening. It ended a bizarre last three innings that kept everyone on the edge of their seats.

A game for the ages.

Facebook Twitter Plusone
Danny Gallagher
About the Author

Danny Gallagher played adult sandlot baseball in various cities across Canada for 27 consecutive seasons. He has covered MLB since 1988, writing three books on the Montreal Expos along the way. Follow Danny on Twitter @dannogallagher7.







if ( function_exists( 'pgntn_display_pagination' ) ) pgntn_display_pagination( 'multipage' );